How to spot a cowboy builder before you hire
Answer first: a cowboy builder usually gives themselves away before any work starts. They want cash with no paperwork, turn up unannounced offering to start tomorrow, ask for a big deposit on the spot, won’t put a quote, address or insurance in writing, and push you to decide now. Get two or three written quotes, check insurance and pay in stages as the work is done.
Key takeaways
- More than 1 in 4 UK adults who had home improvement work done in the past 18 months ran into problems.
- Cash only, doorstep offers, big up-front deposits, no written quote and pressure to decide now are the five big red flags.
- The government’s new Approved Code and Trusted Payments app should help, but it’s still worth doing your own checks.
It usually starts with a knock at the door. “Noticed a few loose tiles on your roof, love. I can sort that for you tomorrow.”
Most tradespeople are brilliant: skilled, honest and proud of their work. But the few who aren’t give the whole industry a bad name, and they can cost homeowners a fortune. According to the government, more than 1 in 4 UK adults who had home improvement work done in the past 18 months ran into problems, and consumers lost £10.3 billion on home and garden maintenance in 2024.
Here’s how to spot the warning signs, and what the government’s new crackdown means for you.
The 5 red flags
1. “Cash only, no paperwork”
A legitimate business will give you a written quote and an invoice. Insisting on cash, with nothing in writing, leaves you with no record of what was agreed and no comeback if it goes wrong.
2. “I can start tomorrow – I’ve got materials left over”
Good tradespeople are usually booked up, especially in autumn. Unsolicited doorstep offers to start straight away, often with “leftover” materials from a job nearby, are a classic warning sign.
3. A big deposit up front – today
Paying something in advance can be reasonable for materials on a large job, but a big deposit demanded on the spot, before anything is in writing, is a red flag. Ideally, pay in stages as the work is completed.
4. No written quote, no address, no insurance
Before anyone starts work, you should have:
- a written quote that sets out the work, the price and the timescale
- a proper business address and landline or mobile number
- proof of insurance
If a trader is vague about any of these, walk away.
5. “Decide now – this price won’t last”
High-pressure tactics are designed to stop you thinking it over or getting another quote. A trustworthy trade will happily give you time.
What the new Approved Code means for homeowners
In late August the government announced a crackdown on cowboy builders. There are two main parts:
- The Approved Code. Firms that sign up must show higher standards of customer service, transparency and dispute resolution. It is run by the Furniture & Home Improvement Ombudsman in partnership with the Chartered Trading Standards Institute. It was due to go live with its first retailers by the end of September 2026 and be fully live by December 2026.
- Trusted Payments. An app that holds your money and releases it as each stage of the project is completed, so you’re not handing over the full amount before the work is done.
Both should make a real difference. But the code is something firms sign up to, so it’s still worth doing your own checks.
Your quick checklist before you hire
- Get at least two or three written quotes
- Check reviews and ask to see examples of recent work
- Confirm the business address, phone number and insurance
- Agree a payment schedule linked to stages of the work, and avoid paying it all up front
- Get any changes to the job agreed in writing
- For gas work, check the engineer is on the Gas Safe Register. For electrical work, ask about their registration and the certificates you’ll receive
Sources: GOV.UK – Government steps in to protect families from cowboy builders · Homebuilding & Renovating – Approved Code scheme
Hire with confidence through DoyouKnowa
DoyouKnowa matches homeowners in Reading, Maidenhead, Wokingham and across Berkshire with local tradespeople, and every suggestion shows whether we’ve checked their ID and insurance. Tell us what you need and we’ll connect you with the right trade, without the ringing round.



